1
$\begingroup$

I have a half cylinder shape, and another half cylinder sketch perpendicular to that first cylinder. I wish to create a "half-dome" between these two surfaces (picture what should look like almost a pill sliced in half, but hollow). Here is my current design:

enter image description here

I want to create the dome between the sketch pictured and the top face of the half-cylinder. I've tried using dome and loft, but am having trouble doing so. I tried using revolve, but I cannot seem to pick a good axis so that it does what I want.

I am new to using Solidworks, but I've used Inventor in a class before and a lot of the features seem fairly similar. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks!

Edit:

I tried adding a center axis to the cylinder and then revolving 180$^\circ$:

enter image description here

Clearly something isn't right; the error says the axis cannot intersect the drawing, but the shape of the revolve seems to be in the right spot. I created an axis on the back of the half-cylinder so it didn't intersect, and the revolve command called it a not acceptable axis.

$\endgroup$
4
  • $\begingroup$ Are you seriously trying to tell us that you do not know how to find the center of the cylinder? No worries solidworks knows how to do this for you. $\endgroup$
    – joojaa
    Jun 22 '18 at 19:17
  • $\begingroup$ @joojoa I can find the center of a cylinder just fine, but I don't know why that's necessary (sorry, new to using solidworks). Also, solidworks doesn't seem to be doing it for me, as all the functions I'm trying aren't working. $\endgroup$ Jun 22 '18 at 19:31
  • $\begingroup$ That centerline is a good axis. $\endgroup$
    – joojaa
    Jun 22 '18 at 19:34
  • $\begingroup$ @joojaa - probably did it wrong, but see the edit. $\endgroup$ Jun 22 '18 at 21:55
1
$\begingroup$

Whenever you are sketching a profile to be revolved in any CAD package, you should start by drawing your axis of revolution into that sketch as a construction line. Then, keep every other line to one side of that axis. In SolidWorks, this gives you the added benefit of being able to dimension diameters, rather than radii, which may be more appropriate. I've shown a 'best practice' sketch below, showing how you can generate the object you're looking for, with just four dimensions, and one revolve feature in the tree. Simply revolve this profile by 180° Best Practice Revolve Sketch

That said, there are of course several other ways to generate the 'half dome', which you are after. I'll go through one of these below. Please note that this is not recommended in this situation but I've included it to give an idea of how to use the tools involved more generally, and to show how many options are present in all situations.

The original question included a question on how to define the axis. If you wanted to revolve your dome in the other direction, then you need to create a 'master' sketch to not only define the axis, but also the plane on which the sketch should be created.

Start by extruding the half-cylinder:

Half Cylinder Extrude

Then on the Right Plane, create a master sketch, which defines the shape of the dome that you would like. This should only contain one driving dimension, You should also add driven dimensions that show the radius of the dome, and the angle of the revolve to come

Master Sketch Demo

Now define a new plane for your sketch. It needs to intersect the centerpoint of the arc in your master sketch. I used the line from that sketch (coincident) and the Right Plane (perpendicular) as my references

Plane Definition

Now, start your sketch for the dome on the new plane. All the dimensions in this sketch should be equation driven, since you've already defined all the geometry elsewhere. Again, remember to put a centreline into your sketch and keep everything else on one side of it. The diameter of the circle should be twice the radius you measured in the master sketch, and the thickness should be equal to that set in your original extrude sketch. This means that if you ever wish to modify the height of the dome, or the diameter of the tube etc., this sketch will automatically rebuild to the correct dimensions.

Equation Driven Sketch

Now you are ready to revolve your dome. Use the angle dimension from your master sketch to define the revolve angle

Equation controlled revolve

You will now be left with a shape which is correct on the inside, but has some undesired overhangs on the outside.

Dome Overhangs

In this case, you could simply run a cut-extrude around the outside, but another way to achieve this (in the spirit of explaining more complex tools for future use) is the 'delete face' tool. Simply delete the face underneath the overhang, with "delete and patch" selected, and SolidWorks will extend the Cylinder face up to meet the dome. You will have to do this once for each overhang. Deleting both at once will not work due to the way both overhang faces meet at a single vertex causing the maths to fall over.

Finished Item

The part has now been completed, and is dimensionally identical to what was achieved with a single revolve previously.

The fundamental concept of master modelling (defining geometry in a sketch that isn't actually used to build the model, and referring to that using equations in order to allow automatic updating of the built geometry) is extremely powerful, however, and in other more complicated examples, it is absolutely the best way to work.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

The basic problem is that it should be a half arc; then it should (and in my case did) work properly with the revolve tool and the center axis.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.