3
$\begingroup$

We're normally paving the high-traffic road with concrete or asphalt. While for sidewalk/garden, we use pave block/tiles (either concrete or else)

Common reason is because pave block/tiles doesn't seems comfortable for high speed vehicle, because it tend to have up-and-down structure, cannot be as plain and smooth as pouring asphalt on it.

While this is true, instead of making pave block/tiles as flat as possible, why do we choose to keep using common surfacing method? Is there any other reason?

Considering from what i understand, in compare to common surfacing method, block/tiles have either environmental, aesthetical or mechanical advantage over it

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Other reasons are: it is faster to create a pavement from either concrete or asphalt, also paving stones can dislodge, creating an uneven surface & if they dislodge they can create a traffic hazard. $\endgroup$ – Fred Jul 7 at 2:39
  • $\begingroup$ And accessibility, there are no cables/sewers below asphalt, but in a regular street/driveway, they are. $\endgroup$ – useless-machine Jul 7 at 21:40
2
$\begingroup$

Engineering decisions are fundamentally about problem solving. Thus, when asking, "Why not do [x] instead of [status quo]?" an answering question is: "What problem does [x] solve or what benefit does [x] provide versus existing designs?" If no satisfactory answer is forthcoming to the second question then that's the answer to the starting question, i.e. [status quo] is a better engineering solution.

When assessing a proposed solution, considerations include: safety, constructibility, initial cost, life-cycle cost, maintainability, aesthetics, etc.

So, how do pavers stack up against existing roadway toppings like asphalt concrete? Overall, I'd say not great. It's likely a more expensive material from the get-go, more expensive and much more laborious to construct, less maintainable, and less safe (the uneven surface issue you identified). Note that roadways are often carefully cambered and banked to ensure proper drainage and safe driving dynamics, so we have the added challenge of actually not wanting a perfectly level surface, but rather a smooth surface that is sloped in a precise way.

It could be argued that stone pavers offer an aesthetic benefit, but the driving surface aesthetics are a low priority for major roadways so the pavers aren't offering much value versus existing engineering solutions.

On personal property like driveways, the aesthetic consideration may be much more significant to the owners, and low driving speeds plus a small project size change the value equation appreciably versus a highly traveled roadway.

From a more big-picture perspective, it's interesting to know that the actual driving surface is only a small part of roadway design. Furthermore, pavement design actually is an active area of Civil Engineering research. I myself am not a roadway or pavement engineer, but having worked with those folks on various projects I can confirm that roadways are carefully designed, both in terms of geometric layout and the 'structural section' that generally extends much deeper than than the final paved surface you can see. An example roadway cross section from the California Department of Transportation Highway Design Manual is included below for illustrative purposes.

Ultimately, I think we can say pavers just don't make the grade for major roadway applications, but innovation in pavement engineering is certainly something engineers and researchers are striving for!

roadway cross section

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

The reason tiles or flagstone or any other finishing is not used for heavy trrafic areas is lack of strength and toughness.

Even in the decks you have attached photos these tiles/ stones will crack and dislodge due to differential heat expansion, vibration and water penetration to adhesive layer. They require a much higher level of maintenance.

For roads and heavy traffic areas there are tested methods and standards worked out over centuries. They have civil engineering courses focused on roads and highway design.

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.