0
$\begingroup$

Stress = Force / Area

Lets see with static force... what happens to stress output when decrease the area.

# Stress = Force / Area 
F = 50000
A = [15.0,10.0,5.0]

S = zero(A) # Initialize the output 
for i in 1:length(A)
    S[i] = F / A[i]
end

m = DataFrame(hcat(A,S))
names = ["area","stress"]
names!(m, Symbol.(names))
print(m)

3×2 DataFrame
│ Row │ area    │ stress  │
│     │ Float64 │ Float64 │
├─────┼─────────┼─────────┤
│ 1   │ 15.0    │ 3333.33 │
│ 2   │ 10.0    │ 5000.0  │
│ 3   │ 5.0     │ 10000.0 │

With decreasing area we increase the stress.

So in thinking about hoop stress then how the minimum required thickness is obtained. Using the ASME B31.3 pressure tmin to find t

304.1.2 Straight Pipe Under Internal Pressure
t = PD / 2(SEW + PY)

The numerator has P * D so anything in the denominator will dilute the numerator...

So to see how P and D affect the t output we can iterate through a range of static pressure and changing Diameter... so lets see what this looks like:

# Define numerator inputs 
P = 200 # static P
D = collect(1.0:1.0:24.0) # varying D

# define the denominator static inputs 
S = 20000
E = 1.0
W = 1.0 
Y = 0.4 # temp coefficient 

# initialize output 
out = zero(D)
for i in 1:length(D)
    out[i] = P * D[i] / (2*(S*E*W) + (P*Y))
end

# plot the output
plot(D,out,seriestype = :bar, title="t = static P in relation to Diameter")

enter image description here

So a big factor in the minimum required thickness for pressure containment is the P vs diameter.. at say static P increase the D and we need a thicker wall for pressure containment.

So in thinking about S = F / A

How does this relate to the pressure design thickness calculation.... S in the tmin calculation is in the denominator and S is static in this equation governed by the 3:1 ASME safety factor in relation to materials tensile stress.

Intuitively i can see how at a static F over varying Area - how the stress INCREASES... (as we saw top of the post) because there is less area to distribute the stress over... so stress would increase pounds per sq inch...

But doesn't that mean for smaller D in a pipe, we have less A so that the stress would increase... but running pressure design thickness calculation.. at smaller D we need a thinner wall for pressure containment.

For sure im missing something here! (then again i see no area in the pressure tmin calculation)

Anyone can help me connect the dots?

Thanks

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

The "area" terms in the equations all cancel out. Think about a section of pipe of internal diameter $d$, length $l$, thickness $t$ with internal pressure $P$.

Now imagine you slice the section of pipe (and the fluid causing the internal pressure) into two semicircular parts, and think about the forces acting one of the parts.

The "area" of the cut through the fluid is d wide by $l$ long, and the fluid pressure of $P$. So the force exerted by the fluid is pressure $\times$ area = $P\,d\,l$.

This is balanced by the hoop stress in the pipe wall. The area of the cut through the walls is $2\,t\,l$ (2, because there are two cuts, on either side of the pipe).

If the average hoop stress is $S$, the force on the cut surfaces of the pipe is stress $\times$ area = $2S\,t\,l$.

So $2Stl = Pdl$ or $$S = \frac{Pd}{2t}.$$

The actual hoop stress varies between the outside and inside of the pipe wall, and this formula doesn't include any safety factors, so in the ASME formula the $2t$ term is replaced by something more realistic for design purposes.

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ 2t term adjusted for temperature coefficients, weld joint quality, reduction factors... id be interested to see a full worked example of the A terms cancelling out just out of interest when simplifying the initial equation. At least to see a higher level view of the simplified equation (not obligated to do so) appreciate the answer and didnt think of splitting in half like that, thanks! $\endgroup$ – Andrew Bannerman Jun 6 '19 at 20:39
  • $\begingroup$ Ok then S = F / A holds true... however Pd is the force which is F = S * A, so P must be a component of Stress. And the Area... 2*t... essentially its 2 because 2x sides of the pipe... but that is cross section thickness as area vs a surface area... so this stress acts on inside and outside... of the pipe wall... so area in this case is just the thickness.... then to solve for t, its a transposed equation of the above variables. $\endgroup$ – Andrew Bannerman Jun 7 '19 at 0:55
  • $\begingroup$ engineersedge.com/material_science/hoop-stress.htm $\endgroup$ – Andrew Bannerman Jun 8 '19 at 2:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.