0
$\begingroup$

when the sides of a pontoon are verticle, BM(distance between center of buoyancy and metacenter) is given by I/V

As well as for a small angle that expression is true. But when the heel angle increases what heppens to the BM?

$\endgroup$
3
  • $\begingroup$ A diagram would help here. $\endgroup$
    – Solar Mike
    Mar 14, 2019 at 15:24
  • $\begingroup$ What happens is we quit calling a metacentric height because that defaults to zero heel (and "height" becomes a bit ambiguous when dealing with multiple heeled states). When running a heel trace, you get a curve tracing the metacenter. You use the waterplane as heeled to get the appropriate I, which is the second moment of area of the waterplane. $\endgroup$
    – Phil Sweet
    Mar 14, 2019 at 22:15
  • $\begingroup$ And closevoters, there is nothing unclear about what he is asking if you know what a metacentric height is. However, I think we need a marine engineering tag. $\endgroup$
    – Phil Sweet
    Mar 14, 2019 at 22:23

1 Answer 1

0
$\begingroup$

Summary No, the metacentric height is no independent of heel angle. For larger heeling angles, $BM$ tend to increase until a crictical point where it will start to decrease again. $BM$ is not easily solved for larger heeling angles.

More in-depth The topic you are adressing – stability at large heeling angles - is a key consideration in the fine art of making ships (and other floating structures) float with the correct side up. It consists of several definitions, curves and helpful figures, most of which I will not adress in this answer.

To understand the stability at large heeling angles, it is first necessary to summarize stability at small heeling angles, that is, the intial stability. As you've correctly stated in your question, the distance between the center of buoyancy $B$ and the metacenter $M$ is given by $BM = I / V$, where $I$ is the second moment of area of the waterplane and $V$ is the volume of displacement. This relation is valid when the sides of the pontoon in question are (close to) verticle. As a general rule of thumb, this relation is valid for heeling angles up to $\approx 10 \,deg$, although this depends on the hull shape.

Image 1 For small heeling angles, the verticales through the buoyancy center will intersect in the same point, called the metacenter $M$ (to be exact, there is a small difference between the intersecting points, but for small angles this is negligible). The heeled center of buoyancy $B'$ is for small angles assumed horizontally displaced from $B$, although the true displacement is both horizontal and vertical. This is an assumption in the derivation of $BM$ stated above. Stability at small heeling angles

For larger heeling angles, the assumptions made for small heeling angles are no longer valid, meaning that the verticals through the bouyancy center at differnt angles are no longer intersecting in the same point, i.e., there is no constant location of the metacenter. When I was taught this, we denoted this constantly varying metacenter as a false metacenter $M^*$, although I have encountered various definitions since. As pointed out by @PhilSweet in the comment, it is therefore common to assosiate the metacenter and the metacentric height with small heeling angles (ideally $0 \, deg$).

Since we no longer can assume $B'$ to be horizontally displaced from $B$, it becomes a lot harder to relate $B$ and $M^*$ (which in turn is used to find the arm of the rightning moment). For the case of vertical sides of the pontoon, you may e.g. use the wall-sided formula, although I will not go into more detail on it here. Nowadays, software may easily compute the location of the heeled buoyancy $B'$ center using the exact hull geometry, which in turn is usually plotted as $GZ$ curves.

Image 2 For large heeling angles, the verticals through the buoyancy center will not intersect at the same point, meaning that the false metacenter $M^*$ is highly dependent on $\phi$. As a consequency, $BM$ is not easily computed by hand, but most often requires the appropriate software. Stability at large heeling angles

To keep this answer somewhat short, I will not go into any more detail, but rather suggest those curious to dive into the appropriate literature. My suggestion includes, but is not limited to the book; Ship Stability for Masters and Mates by C.B. Barrass and D.R. Derrett.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.