I am trying to build a super-efficient electric boat. The dilemma I am coming across is this:

In normal long range running mode the boat will go at a slow 2.5 knots and only require 400 W power. This is the optimally efficient setting through the water. However for safety and practicality reasons like getting around in high winds etc I still need about 5kw max power available on the shaft. From my understanding any electric motor with a 5 kW capacity will be very inefficient at 400 W.

So my proposed solution is to put 2 motors on one shaft, a small one optimized for 400 W and a big one, the small one will be rigidly connected to the shaft and the big one via a clutch. I will then manually manually engage and disengage the large motor with a switch.

Can you please advise if this is a normal approach of if there is a better way to handle my situation? Am I misunderstanding something or reinventing the wheel?


While the mechanism you described will produce greater motor efficiency than turning down a 5kW motor to less than 10%, you will lose overall system reliability IMHO with the clutch/2 motor system.

The clutch/2 motor system should work as described, but why not just use a VFD?


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.