Recently came across the following 2-minute YouTube video that claims A Balanced Rig Saves Fuel
While nicely done, it is a marketing video. Does anyone know of any unbiased studies that support the claim?
Engineering Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for professionals and students of engineering. It only takes a minute to sign up.Sign up to join this community
Consider to simplify the model to two wheels in line as in a bicycle. For nice round figures, the tires are inflated to 100 pounds per square inch.
The load is two hundred pounds and is placed over the rear tire in such a way as to fully load the rear axle and completely unload the front.
The footprint of the rear tire is now two square inches.
In order to accomplish that footprint, the tire has to deflect along the sidewalls in such a manner as to substantially distort the rubber. This distortion absorbs energy that would otherwise be used to propel the vehicle.
A similar situation is in place when a tire is underinflated. I have a cart similar to that shown in the video. When it is heavily loaded and the tires are at 45 psi, the cart rolls easily. One can allow that the tire footprint matches more appropriately the engineering of the tire and that sidewall flex is at a minimum.
When the tire is underinflated (often!) at say, 20 psi, the footprint is greater, the flex is greater and it sure is much more difficult to pull when loaded.
For a vehicle such as a semitrailer rig, heavy loads over one axle would not necessarily cause visible sidewall flex, but it could be mechanically significant.
The above assessment is a simplification, but appears in the video to be substantiated by the rolling cart test process. When you see someone pulling an airliner with his teeth, you can bet the load is evenly distributed and the tires are either properly inflated or are over-inflated for the purpose of the demonstration.