1
$\begingroup$

It looks like the digging of this ISIL tunnel introduced periodic waviness in the sidewalls of the tunnel. Similar (related?) waviness can sometimes be observed on dirt roads. What is the origin of that periodic waviness?

enter image description here(source)

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ What exactly are you talking about? It is a rough stone wall. If you are talking about the bottom, it seems very likely that the miners intentionally included steps. $\endgroup$ – hazzey Apr 13 '17 at 18:30
  • $\begingroup$ @hazzey the periodic waviness is most visible at the top left in the picture. The stone wall is rough, but not random. There are obvious contours all along the tunnel. $\endgroup$ – Sparkler Apr 13 '17 at 18:42
  • $\begingroup$ The most likely explanation for the waviness pattern is improper blasting practices leaving toe (the ridges) behind, particularly in the floor of the tunnel. In some case the ridging of the toe continues up the walls. It looks like the bottom row of blast holes weren't low enough & they were angled downwards. $\endgroup$ – Fred Apr 14 '17 at 12:43
1
$\begingroup$

The most likely explanation for the waviness pattern is improper drilling and blasting practices leaving toe (the ridges) behind, particularly in the floor of the tunnel. In some case the ridging of the toe continues up the walls. It looks like the bottom row of blast holes (the lifters) weren't low enough & they weren't angled downwards.

From the limited information provided by the picture, the rock through which the tunnel was excavated looks competent. Using manual pick against such rock would be very difficult. The most likely way the tunnel was excavated was to use drill and blast techniques.

From the height & width of the tunnel, the most likely method of drilling would have been to use a jack leg (also known as an air leg) drill, similar to the one pictured below. Such drills are pneumatically operated. They can be powered using common air compressors, with holes linking the jack leg drill to the air compressor.

Compressed air not only provides power for the drill itself, but also extends the telescopic leg which continually forces the drill and drill steel into the rock face as drilling advances.

This is relatively easy to do for holes bored into the rock face from waist height upwards. Below waist height the telescopic jack leg can have difficultly getting a good enough grip to provide the force required to keep the drill steel drilling efficiently.

The bottom row of holes, technically referred to as the lifter holes, need to be drilled as close to the bottom of the face (tunnel heading) as possible – preferably in the corner of the face and the floor. For this to happen, the jack leg drill needs to be placed horizontally on the floor of the tunnel.

In that position, the jack leg won’t have anything to push against. Typically, to drill lifter holes with a jack leg drill the miners/tunnelers would secure a steel ladder to the floor of the tunnel and place the bottom of the jack leg against a rung of the ladder to give the jack leg something to push against so the lifter holes can be drilled.

From the height of the ridges left in the floor of the tunnel I am speculating the people who excavated the tunnel didn’t use a steel ladder bolted to the floor to get the lifter holes in the correct location.

I am also assuming that ammonium nitrate fuel oil (ANFO) was used as the main explosive for blasting. With the correct equipment it can be easily made.

Technically, ANFO is a blasting agent, not an explosive, because it can’t be detonated using a blasting cap, it needs a high energy explosive (like dynamite or another type of “stick” explosive) to set it off.

When charging tunneling blast holes, the high energy explosive, with a blasting cap inserted, is placed in the toe of the hole (far end of the hole). ANFO is then pneumatically forced into the rest of the hole.

The highest energy part of the blast is always at the end of the drill holes. If the holes weren’t properly, or fully filled with ANFO, the collar end of the hole (at the face) may receive substantially less blast energy and this may not be enough to break the rock at the bottom of the face, thus potentially leaving a ridge in the floor.

The spacing of the ridges, in the picture, appears to be relatively uniform, which would confirm a certain length of drill steel was used in drill all the holes for each of the faces during tunnel advance.

Tunneling via drill and blast rarely produces a smooth tunnel throughout. There are always gouges throughout because of inconsistent or poor drilling and blasting practices or the nature of the rock the tunnel is being developed through.

The other thing the tunnelers didn’t do was to backfill the floor of tunnel with road base or gravel, some form of smaller rock during excavation. That would have produced a smoother floor in the tunnel.

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Err, I'm not sure that applying standard excavation practices to this question is relevant. Have you see the guy in the balaclava with the assault rifle? He's probably a western contractor or Kurdish fighter. ISIS wouldn't use ANFO as proper stuff like CB and C4 are widely available. The floor's uneven because that's a set of stairs. Back fill, road base ? Really? $\endgroup$ – Paul Uszak Apr 14 '17 at 18:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.